Strangers and Kindness in Jewish Peoplehood: Complement or Conflict?

By Elana Sztokman

The Jewish Peoplehood Hub, November 2010

When humanitarian crisis strikes around the world, the ensuing dilemmas that Israel and the Jewish People face highlight a central issue in the discussion of Jewish Peoplehood. Social ills such as poverty and homelessness, as well as global crises such as the recent genocide in Darfur, challenge the Jewish community to stand up and assist fellow human beings. However, there are two competing responses to this humanitarian challenge: one is that the value of kindness is paramount, and should be extended to non-Jews, and the second is that kindness only belongs "in-house." This debate, which has occupied Jewish leaders -- religious and political -- for centuries if not millennia, reflects two competing notions about the Divine mission of the Jewish People. Although the precept of "ani'ei irkha" (that the poor of your city comes first) has widespread acceptance within the Jewish community, it is arguably a fallacious misrepresentation of core Jewish values, masking stronger historical support for a Jewish duty to engage in global humanitarian assistance. The original usage of the phrase "ani'ei irkha" refers to a specific form of economic triage, when one only has enough money to lend a single person and has to make difficult choices. While acknowledging that life sometimes presents thorny problems, the original text was perhaps never intended to suggest that one should completely avoid assisting non- Jewish poor people. Unfortunately, that is how the precept is often interpreted today. This troubling interpretation has become an underlying if unspoken element of some versions of Jewish Peoplehood which view the goal of Peoplehood as bolstering an insular fortitude rather than exploring a moralethical stance vis-a-vis the rest of the world.

Topic: Morality, Tzedakah (Charity), Peoplehood, Social Justice, Communal Responsibility, Sectarianism, Charitable Giving, Ethics, Values, Global Responsibility

Name of Publication: The Peoplehood Papers

Editor: Ravid, Shlomi

Volume/Issue: Volume 6

Page Number(s): 10-12

Funder: Jewish Agency for Israel (JAFI) , Nadav Fund , UJA-Federation of New York

Preview: Download

It appears you do not have a PDF plugin installed for this browser. To be able to preview the PDF, please install a PDF reader such as Adobe Reader.

Genre: Essay

Coverage: World

Language: English

Copyright Holder: Publisher

Copyright Information: Download for personal use, freely distribute link

Bibliographic Information:
Sztokman, Elana. Strangers and Kindness in Jewish Peoplehood: Complement or Conflict?. The Peoplehood Papers. The Jewish Peoplehood Hub. November 2010: 10-12.


» View Publication
(PDF, 353 Kb)

Bookmark and Share